Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mika Cooper's avatar

I don't usually chime in here, but I thought I'd just pop in to register my interest in, but disagreement with, your claims. When I say that a suitcase is full, I usually mean that something occupies every part of it; but if I say that a suitcase is very full, then I mean that it is essentially stuffed to its limit (& I would use those words similarly about my stomach after a meal). So, for me, "very full" is always more, not less, full than just "full." A library reading room or train car or automobile engine that is very quiet, in my ordinary usage, is certainly quieter than one that is merely quiet. I suppose you may really be commenting not on the actual meaning of "very" in those cases but on what it leads you to imagine about the circumstances under which it's uttered. Personally, I have less hope of an empty seat beside me when the flight attendant announces a "very full"—rather than simply a "full"—flight. But maybe I take things too literally. My own usage of "very" alongside "soon" aligns with my usage of it alongside "full" (i.e. always as an intensifier), but I won't deny that if I heard it used in the example you offer, I might come to a similar conclusion.

Expand full comment
Steve Marbit's avatar

Here's another one: "So perfect" is less perfect than "perfect".

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts